SMEpal

Custom ROMs, Manufacturers, and Consumers

Posted on 18 March 2010 by Mister Mobility

Custom ROMS abound on a variety of mobile platforms. They usually spring from attempts by users to address one or more core and unresolved failings in a device’s firmware.

Take the modding scene for the Samsung i8910 HD, for example: Samsung promised a device that offered 720p video recording at 24fps, but that came out delivering much less on both audio and video formats. Samsung later released a fix for the audio, but that only messed up the video some more, leaving users with a bitter taste in the mouth. In addition, a powerful multimedia device such as the i8910 should not come with the 18mb free space on drive :C, as it does (latest firmware).

Thanks to the modding scene, Samsung’s failings with that device have now been addressed.

  • Faster operation, more free space on disk C: (around 80MB! The official latest Samsung firmware has only about 18MB free)
  • Full 24fps 720p video recording with higher quality audio capture; using the same settings as Vivaz
  • Pre-autofocus in video recorder; re-enabling what Samsung couldn’t make work in the prototype firmwares
  • Full kinetic scrolling across whole interface
  • Better theme transitions

Source

This scenario of a lone individual or a group of individuals so improving on a device that the results produce a much better device can be replicated across other mobile platforms. For example, a great deal of such work goes on at XDA Developers.

The subject of the necesitty of custom ROMs naturally raise a few issues, which we present below.

Manufacturers
Why is it so hard for manufacturers to deliver devices with optimised firmware and that deliver what was promised? For example, is it so hard for Samsung to produce the same results as obtains with the HX-V3-17 custom ROM? Or Nokia with its litany of crippled devices?

Why sell crippled devices in the first place? Are there no testing procedures or is it that commercial interests override these? What of consumer protection? Any channels for legal redress?

Where a manufacturer has pushed out a crippled device, they should push out firmwares to resolve any issues as fast as possible as a matter of integrity and best business practice. A situation in which firmware issues remain unresolved a year after a device’s release is simply unacceptable.

Lastly, we love the way that Android handles firmare updates – even the most technology-ignorant users can get their devices updated with the latest firmware. Its all done over-the-air and in the background, though the option to do it manually is available as well.

Asking users to go through complex procedures of updating firmware by installing PC suite and connecting phones by data cable, backing up user data et al is simply ice-age and so not user-friendly. We would love to see the day that all manufacturers implement background OTA updates.

Consumers
If you have had the bitter pill of buying a device that does not deliver on its promises forced down your throat and you really want to get the best of your device via custom ROMs, do note the following:

  1. custom ROMs invalidates your warranty (but what good is the warranty offered by a manufacturer if they can’t even deliver on their promise?)
  2. the risk of bricking your phone (rendering it unusable) is always there. If it happens, you are on your own
  3. lastly, the search for improvements to a device can be time-consuming and addictive. Depending on how busy you are with real life, it may turn out to be a tremendous consumer of your precious time flashing and trying out one ROM after the other

This post was written by

Mister Mobility – who has written 926 posts on Mobility blog.

Founder, Mobility blog, serial lifestyle entrepreneur, speaker, & writer. Charming, passionate, tenacious & non-conformist. Will dance! Follow him on Twitter @Mister_Mobility.

Send an Email

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Related posts:

  1. My Experience with Flashing ROMs
  2. What Consumers Care About and the Success of Products
  3. Windows Mobile 6.5 ROMs Everywhere
  4. From Raw Features to Great User Experience: the Consumers Vote
  5. How to set up a Custom Lock Pattern on your Android device

5 Comments For This Post

  1. Azeez Saheed Says:
    Browsing with Opera Mini 4.2.13337 Opera Mini 4.2.13337 on J2ME/MIDP Device J2ME/MIDP Device

    You got it wrong when u said some manufacturers will ask phone users to install PC Suite on computer and connect their phones by data cable before firmware updates can be done. From the mention of PC Suite, I know you are refering to Nokia.

    I ve done quite a large number of updates on my Nokia phones & they were all done over the air (no PC Suite, no tethering of my phone to the computer with data cable). I want to also point out that I dont usually do BACKUP before starting those OTA firmware updates.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. Admin Says:
    Browsing with Firefox 3.6 Firefox 3.6 on Windows XP Windows XP

    From the mention of PC Suite, I know you are refering to Nokia

    Azeez, your adventure into mind-reading failed badly. Honestly, attempting to read meanings into what others say is bad practice. It almost always backfires, one way or the other.

    Sorry, but we had no manufacturer in mind when we wrote about updates via PC Suite. Do you really think that the people behind MobilityNigeria would not know that some of the most recent Nokia smartphones offer over-the-air firmware updates and with User Data Preservation (UDP)?

    If you really think we are that ignorant, this site is not worth your time or that of any serious-minded person.

    Why would our statement about PC Suite be a definite reference to Nokia when every other smartphone manufacturer has PC Suite in one form or the other? To be sure, LG, Samsung, and Sony Ericsson are examples and all these manufacturers have handsets that require PC Suite for their firmware updates.

    Please abstain from reading hidden meanings into any statements we make. If we want to rant at Nokia or Samsung or Apple, we have no problems with mentioning their names and we will provide specific examples of the issues we have with them. If we don’t mention names, we have none in mind.

    Thanks.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  3. Johnny Says:
    Browsing with Nokia Web Browser Nokia Web Browser on Nokia 6030 Nokia 6030

    I got a motorola l6 some days back and have been learning how to install custom firmware, as this was my first time doing this i had to take my time to ensure i didn’t brick the phone, anyway i finally installed a patch firmware and the result was amazing for a phone of its time. What i got was the ability to transfer all files vai blue tooth, acces to all system files, editing of txt docs, play mp4 videos, record videos of any length, ability to change skins and redesign the interface, an additional interface with media viewer corelet and the ability to back up my back up my contact list with out the phone cd.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  4. Yom Says:
    Browsing with Jasmine 1.0 Jasmine 1.0 on Samsung S8003 Samsung S8003

    Johnny,

    Sounds like you had fun! Enjoy.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  5. belushi Says:
    Browsing with Google Chrome 4.1.249.1042 Google Chrome 4.1.249.1042 on Windows 7 Windows 7

    Hello Yomi. i finally i get to meet a nigerian who has successfully installed custom rom on the x1. i have an x1 as well and really interested in making it run on the touch x u suggested. Can you help give a step by step detail on how to do this?

    My x1 came with manufacturer software and not a carrier’s (orange, t-mobile, vodafone e.t.c). i am tired of just installing 3rd party apps on my fones.. i want to join the bleeding users as u grouped them). i have had so much fun with my x1. though looking at moving to the HTC HD2 later in the year when it becomes less expensive. But b4 then, i want to have the custom rom touch x running on my x1.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Advertise Here
Advertise Here

Text Ads

 

Turbo-charged Website Design

We design & code superb websites! Visit Alireta for details

 

Free "Unlimited" Web Hosting

Enjoy the best web hosting services with UNLIMITED features FREE for a whole year, no strings attached. Visit www.arthurwales.com/promo for details

 

Advertise in our Classifieds

N5,000 per month. Mail business@mobility.com.ng for enquiries.

 

RELATED SITES

  • SMEpal PR, publicity and exposure for small/medium enterprises
  • WapReview Covering the mobile web since 2004

Be Notified of New Posts

Your Email:

SpreadMedia

Switch to our mobile site